Manhattan

Audience Reviews

View More

Blake- N @PBSAniDom Apr 22 There’s no denying that Manhattan is a beautifully shot, sharply written film with some of the most iconic black-and-white cinematography ever put on screen. The Gershwin score, the city itself, and the conversational rhythm give it a distinctive identity that’s hard to replicate. That said, it doesn’t quite reach S-tier status for me. The emotional core feels uneven, with relationships that often come across more self-indulgent than genuinely resonant. Some of the dialogue, while witty, leans more toward intellectual posing than real human depth. There’s also a detachment in the characters that keeps the film from fully landing its emotional weight. The film is still excellent—clearly a 9/10—but its tone and thematic distance prevent it from hitting that rare, flawless "all-time masterpiece" tier. It’s more of a stylish, intellectually engaging snapshot of a city and its people than a universally affecting drama. See more matt p @RT09790479 Dec 1 brilliant...... but highly problematic a film you will love or loath //but has ny city ever been more spectacular in american film?? and any film with diane keaton and meryl streep is worth experiencing See more Stephen C @bob25009 Oct 15 Funny in 1 hour and 36 minutes. See more Faiz D @RT95588871 05/13/2025 Manhattan is a warm and emotionally resonant tale about love, loss and being true to one's self. See more jacob c @RT09118617 04/30/2025 Manhattan is a funny and heartfelt film exploring a wide range of themes, such as love, loyalty, and complex relationships with great sincerity and realism. The film is also wonderfully shot and brilliantly acted, and the ending gave me goosebumps. See more Bradley S @RT52236733 03/05/2025 Only bettered by Annie Hall, this is a nostalgic Allen Classic. Engaging, thought provoking dialogue which captures not only life's deeper considerations but also the whimsical chaotic. Turn the lights off, bring out the popcorn and let me be whisked away by the cosmic delights. See more Read all reviews

Manhattan

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING